Talk:Honor Guard: Difference between revisions

(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)

Line 11:

This should be one of our shining pages. Loaded with history and in general, a more entertaining read. I will strive to make this page a priority over the next few weeks and months.

--[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 16:02, 15 April 2014 (PDT)

== Membership Timeline ==

* Right now, the section title suggests a definite list of Honor Guard members at any given moment in time. In actuality, and given the limited knowledge presented in the stories, this timeline is more a listing of the members(active, temporary, honorary, guest, or being considered - we don't know for sure) that appeared during a particular event. It is also a bit repetitive of the Cases and Adventures page. I suggest merging this section onto that page and remove it from here. --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 08:38, 29 October 2014 (PDT)

* I've re-titled "Former" to "Inactive" and "Current" to "Active" This in an attempt to avoid definitively labeling the status of a particular character. It still feels "spongy" but short of putting speculation commentary around each and every member it seems to work, in a spongy kind of way. --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 08:09, 30 September 2015 (PDT)

== Headlines the old manual method and the auto-generated method ==

Note: This will probably be moved to the Community portal, but for now it is specific for this one particular call-out

The '''Headline''' entry that was manually here, ''"Honor Guard Routes Aliens"'' doesn't seem to be on the event list that is auto-generated. I may have missed it, so correct me if I am wrong. But since it has yet to be built, how about not deleting the manual information unless you are also providing the mechanisms for generating the auto-magical entry. If we get into that habit of assuming that future actions will make current information redundant, it will cause a bit of confusion, and lost info. Because based on that pattern, and assuming I can get the time and motivation to formulate methods for well formatted and sorted queries, manual appearance lists would be going, going, gone too. --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 11:00, 4 April 2017 (PDT)

@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 This should be one of our shining pages. Loaded with history and in general, a more entertaining read. I will strive to make this page a priority over the next few weeks and months.
 --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 16:02, 15 April 2014 (PDT)
+== Membership Timeline ==
+* Right now, the section title suggests  a definite list of Honor Guard members at any given moment in time. In actuality, and given the limited knowledge presented in the stories, this timeline is more a listing of the members(active, temporary, honorary, guest, or being considered -  we don't know for sure) that appeared during a particular event.  It is also a bit repetitive of the Cases and Adventures page. I suggest merging this section onto that page and remove it from here.  --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 08:38, 29 October 2014 (PDT)
+* I've re-titled "Former" to "Inactive" and "Current" to "Active"   This in an attempt to avoid definitively labeling the status of a particular character.  It still feels "spongy" but short of putting speculation commentary around each and every member it seems to work, in a spongy kind of way. --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 08:09, 30 September 2015 (PDT)
+== Headlines the old manual method and the auto-generated method ==
+Note: This will probably be moved to the Community portal, but for now it is specific for this one particular call-out
+The '''Headline''' entry that was manually here, ''"Honor Guard Routes Aliens"'' doesn't seem to be on the event list that is auto-generated. I may have missed it, so correct me if I am wrong.   But since it has yet to be built, how about not deleting the manual information unless you are also providing the mechanisms for generating the auto-magical entry.  If we get into that habit of assuming that future actions will make current information redundant, it will cause a bit of confusion, and lost info.  Because based on that pattern, and assuming I can get the time and motivation to formulate methods for well formatted and sorted queries, manual appearance lists would be going, going, gone too. --[[User:Infobroker|Infobroker]] ([[User talk:Infobroker|talk]]) 11:00, 4 April 2017 (PDT)